This report marks the second instalment of Movemeon’s Quarterly Hiring Analysis — a regular update designed to help hiring managers and candidates stay ahead of the market across Private Equity, VC-backed scale-ups and large Enterprise businesses. Our insights are powered by over 1.8 million data points from the Movemeon platform, giving you a clear picture of how candidate interest and hiring demand are shifting.

At the heart of this analysis is the Movemeon Hiring Index — a scale from 0 to 100 that reflects how attractive the job market is for employers. In short: a higher index means higher candidate interest per role. When the economy slows, candidate supply tends to rise, pushing the index up. When hiring demand picks up and candidate availability falls, the index drops.

To find out more about hiring with Movemeon get in touch with our team here.

‍

‍

This quarter, we’ve seen a strengthening in the hiring market.

After 6 months in the second half of last year with a value between 90 and 100 (the highest values we’d seen, indicating high interest in new roles), the index dropped to 75 in January and 80 in February. 

We look at the drivers of this change, highlighting how a drop in the freelance market index pre-empted a drop in the permanent market index. We then look at how these trends have varied depending upon industry, finding that Private Equity is starting to lose it’s talent edge, just as there has been increased demand for hiring in the market. 

We conclude that all the drivers are there for a war for talent, but that this is likely to be localised initially to Private Equity backed-companies where we’re seeing both higher hiring demand coupled with a slight decrease in candidate supply. We forecast this to further expand into consulting and potentially corporates, driven by increased demand and reduced supply respectively.

‍

The Movemeon talent index

The Index is designed to give employers a read on the talent market: is it competitive? Are candidates open to new roles? Are certain industries or job types seeing more traction than others?

Below is how the index has changed over the last five years. For context, it's worth understanding who the Movemeon community are:

• It’s global: our 90k members are based across the world, with our main hubs in the UK, France, DACH, the Middle East, APAC and the US
• Everyone has worked in a leading consulting or accounting firm: 45% are ex-McKinsey, BCG and Bain; 30% are leading strategy firms; the remainder are the Big4
• They are future leaders and Board members: consultancies make up six of the top eight "CEO factories" (companies whose alumni become CEOs of the largest businesses. And this isn't constrained to just large businesses, with a disproportionate number of unicorns founded by consulting alumni

‍

‍

The freelance and permanent markets have broadly mirrored one another, although freelance has moved first and seen more rapid fluctuations

The freelance and interim market has broadly mirrored the permanent one, but tends to shift first — reacting more quickly to changes in business needs and macroeconomic signals. This can be seen by the permanent having a slight lag from the freelance index, as well as often slightly dampened highs and lows.

‍

‍

‍

‍

When we look at the index at a company level, we can see hiring is the hardest it has been for the past year, especially in consulting and corporates

Candidate interest in consulting and corporate roles is now at a one-year low. These sectors are beginning to feel the effects of tightening supply. In contrast, PE-backed companies — where hiring demand remains strong — are still benefiting from relatively high candidate availability, but that gap is closing thanks to slight increases in interest in start-ups/scale-ups as well as consulting. 

‍

‍

Is the war for top talent about to heat up again?

‍

The phrase “war for talent” was first coined by McKinsey in the late ’90s and resurfaced in 2022 during the Great Resignation and post-COVID hiring boom. Are we seeing a resurgence?

The answer lies in the balance between:

1. Candidate supply (captured by our Hiring Index captures)
   
   
2. Employer demand (based on volume and growth of roles posted)
   
   

What we’re seeing is clear: Q1 2025 was the busiest hiring quarter since early 2022. This suggests that overall demand is returning — and it’s being led by Private Equity.

In fact, PE’s share of total hiring demand has grown significantly over the past two years. As deal volume picks up and portfolio businesses push ahead with transformation plans, the ‘war for talent’ is likely to intensify, albeit localised at first.

‍

‍

‍

Whilst we expect this war for talent to be highly localised to Private Equity initially, we are forecasting that it will expand into consulting and corporates over the course of the next year. The expansion into consulting will predominantly be demand led: increased deal flow will result in more consulting work, which will mean more hiring in a slightly dampened market. For corporates the challenge will be supply led: their historic disadvantage in hiring ex-consulting talent compared with PE or consulting has further widened, meaning a small increase in demand will have a big impact.

‍

To find out more about hiring with Movemeon get in touch with our team here.

‍

Leaving consulting for other industries is more common than staying. Many consultants move on after a few years, whether for career progression, better work-life balance, or the opportunity to take on ownership roles. If you're wondering about jobs after consulting, here’s what you need to know.

Looking for expert coaching to support your career transition? Visit OnUpBeyond for tailored career advice and coaching resources.

Why Do Consultants Leave?

From our discussions with Movemeon users and insights from our jobs board, these are the key reasons consultants transition to new roles:

• Up or out model: The traditional consulting pyramid structure pushes many professionals to leave after a few years.
• Career stepping stone: Many enter consulting with the intention of leaving once they’ve gained skills and built a network.
• Work-life balance: Long hours and frequent travel can make consulting unsustainable in the long run.
• Transferable skills: Consultants develop highly sought-after skills that are valuable across industries, from startups to private equity.
• Desire to execute: Many consultants want to move beyond advising and start executing strategies themselves.

Related Reading

• Post-Consulting Opportunities: What Pays Best?
• How to write a consulting resume - tips from an ex-consultant

Best Jobs After Consulting

Based on over 20,000 applications on Movemeon, here are the top industries for ex-consultants:

1. Corporate & Enterprise

‍Large companies actively recruit former consultants, often placing them in higher-level roles than their non-consulting peers. The most common functions include:

• Strategy & Transformation (Internal Strategy, Corporate Development)
• Operations & Supply Chain Management
• Growth and Business Development
• Corporate Finance
• Technology & Digital Transformation

Why consultants are a good fit:

• Experience in market research, competitor analysis, and operational improvements translates well into strategy roles.
• Consultants are skilled at navigating cross-functional teams and driving strategic initiatives.
• These roles offer a better work-life balance while still leveraging a consulting background.

Find out more about how to thrive in the corporate environment in our interviews with leaders.

‍

2. Startups & Growth Companies

‍Startups offer a fast-paced, dynamic environment for consultants looking to apply problem-solving skills in a hands-on way. Ex-consultants often join startups as:

• Founders or Co-Founders
• COOs or Strategy Leads
• Chief of Staff
• Product or Growth Managers

Why consultants are a good fit:

• Consultants thrive in fast-paced, high-growth environments with shifting priorities.
• Experience in scaling operations, business development, and fundraising is highly valuable.
• Ability to identify growth opportunities and operational efficiencies makes them strong startup leaders.
• Exposure to digital transformation projects provides a foundation for tech-driven environments.

Find out what it's like to be a Chief of Staff in our interview with Penfold CoS, Aidan Curran.

‍

3. Freelance & Boutique Consulting

‍For those who enjoy consulting but want more flexibility, freelancing or starting a boutique firm can be a great path. Benefits include:

• Autonomy over projects
• Higher earning potential per engagement
• Ability to specialise in a niche industry

Why consultants are a good fit:

• Broad expertise across industries makes consultants versatile for short-term strategic projects.
• Companies seek independent consultants for executive-level advisory and transformation work.
• Freelancing provides a flexible career path with strong earning potential.
  ‍

4. Private Equity & Venture Capital

‍Many ex-consultants transition into private equity (PE) or venture capital (VC) due to their strong financial and strategic skills. Typical roles include:

• Investment Associate or Principal
• Portfolio Operations Manager
• Strategy or Due Diligence Lead

Why consultants are a good fit:

• Consultants excel at financial modeling, due diligence, and market analysis, all essential in investment decisions.
• Strong experience working with C-suite executives makes them well-suited for portfolio company strategy.
• Ability to structure ambiguous problems and make data-driven recommendations aligns with PE/VC deal-making.

‍

Common Challenges When Leaving Consulting
‍

1. Adapting to Corporate Hierarchies

‍Consultants used to flat structures may find corporate bureaucracy challenging. To navigate this, they should focus on building internal relationships, understanding decision-making processes, and adapting to longer project timelines. Seeking mentors within the organisation and leveraging their problem-solving skills to improve efficiency can also help ease the transition.

2. Adjusting to Execution-Oriented Roles

‍Unlike consulting, where advising is the focus, industry roles require direct ownership and execution. Former consultants can ease this transition by:

• Prioritising hands-on experience early
• Learning operational intricacies of their new industry
• Collaborating closely with teams to drive outcomes

3. Managing Work-Life Balance

‍Some industries, like startups and PE, can be as demanding as consulting, requiring careful career planning. Former consultants should set clear work boundaries and seek roles that align with their lifestyle goals.
‍

FAQs
‍

What functions within big corporates attract ex-consultants the most?

• Internal strategy, corporate development, operations, product management, and digital transformation teams commonly hire consultants.
• The choice depends on personal interests, industry trends, and networking.

What’s the biggest difference between consulting and startups?

• Consulting firms are structured and process-driven, while startups are dynamic and fast-moving.
• Consultants transitioning to startups should develop technical skills, embrace ambiguity, and be prepared for hands-on work.

How do I choose the right career path?

• What energises you? Do you prefer structured environments (corporate strategy) or high-risk, high-reward roles (startups/VC)?
• ‍Do you want financial stability or flexibility? PE and corporate roles offer strong salaries, while freelancing provides greater independence.
• ‍What industries excite you? Consider which sectors align with your interests and skill set.

Check out Movemeon member, Jonny's story of leaving consulting, joining a startup and going through IPO.

‍

Find Your Next Role

Looking for your next step after consulting? Explore current opportunities on Movemeon.com.

Build Your Career with Movemeon:‍

• Solve a business challenge – Hire a Movemeon professional
• Advance your career – Coaching and courses for ex-consultants
• Join 40,000+ followers – Get insights on careers after consulting from our Co-Founder, Rich

2024 was a tough year to find a new role; what we’re doing to support you in 2025

‍

2024 was a tough market to find a new job. We wanted to write this note, firstly to recognise the challenging market but also to explain what Movemeon is doing to help.

‍

Whilst we’re proud to have grown by 15% as a business last year, we’re aware that demand for roles was at a decade-long high. Uncertainty in employers’ hiring plans has meant our values of full transparency have, at times, been hard to uphold. We implemented a number of key initiatives to make sure you were still hearing about every opportunity we were working on, and were receiving responses, and feedback, to any application you made.

‍

This year, we are focused on offering even more to our community:

1. Uncovering more opportunities for you: we shared 900 roles last year (15% more than the previous year); for 2025, we’ve built a new team to uncover more opportunities relevant to you, and have grown our US and APAC teams.
2. Getting you to interview: how you are presented really matters. Last year we focused on improving screening questions to drive to the best case for an interview. This year, we’re looking to further improve how you’re presented. 
3. Getting feedback from every application: last year, 93.6% of applicants heard back within two weeks. Our focus this year is making that feedback as actionable and constructive as possible.
4. Coaching service: we launched courses, coaching, and roundtables with a peer group of like-minded professionals to help you progress in your career in 2024. We’re going to be rapidly growing this offering in 2025.
5. Executive Search proposition: as our community has got more experienced, we’ve increasingly worked on C-level roles (Chief Transformation Officer, Operating Partner, Chief Strategy Officer). To ensure you get access to more of these roles, we’re launching a Search level service for our PE and Enterprise clients in 2025.
6. More insights and data: to help you make informed career decisions. This year we’ll be crunching even more of our compensation and hiring trend data, and sharing these insights with you more regularly.

‍

How you can help one another

‍

If there’s one thing you can do to help one another - it’s sharing relevant roles in your team/ company (“paying it forward”). 80% of our jobs last year came from our community - so thanks to all of you who have shared roles already. If you or one of your colleagues is hiring, click below and we can set up some time to see how we can help (data, insight, job description, hiring):

‍

‍

2024 was a tough year to move jobs

‍

2024 was a tough market to find a new job. Our recruitment index showed as much, with demand for roles at a decade-long high. Whilst great news for companies hiring, it meant it was a very hard year for those who were looking for their next opportunity.

‍

We’re very proud that Movemeon grew by 15%, and most importantly connected more than 2,500 of you with interviews at exciting companies. However, the tough market meant living up to our values was harder than ever before. 

‍

We built Movemeon out of our frustration with the lack of transparency in recruitment. Our values are therefore focused on empowering you in your job search: we show you all jobs for you to discover, as opposed to only calling a select few people. Uncertainties in employers’ hiring plans, longer interview processes, and increased competition, has meant our approach of full transparency has been hard: at times it would be easier not to market roles to everyone; and at times it would be easier to not give the full picture on hiring processes. However, this transparency is why we set up Movemeon, and know it’s what you value. We are therefore even more proud that our team has upheld these values during a tough market. 

‍

Uncovering more opportunities for you

‍

We built Movemeon to help you discover great opportunities you wouldn’t have found elsewhere. We were frustrated with traditional recruitment companies, and wanted to know what jobs there were out there that would be a good fit with our experience.

‍

Whilst we were proud to be able to share over 900 jobs with you last year, we are also aware that there are plenty more opportunities out there, and that we owe it to you to find them. We’ve therefore proactively been building our US and APAC teams - markets which are seeing rapid growth, and places we know many of you are.

‍

We’ve been very lucky that our community (you!) shares opportunities in their team when they’re hiring. Given you understand our proposition, you know that working with us ensures you reach the best in the market. If there’s one way you can help each other, it’s paying it forward by sharing these roles. If you have any potential opportunities, please don’t hesitate to get in contact:

‍

‍

We have also worked hard over the last year on building a new team to identify new roles more proactively. All with the single aim of making it easier for community members to share roles with us. Early indications are positive, with 55% more jobs posted in Q4 2024 than in Q4 2023.

‍

Getting you to interview

‍

How you’re presented really matters. 

‍

On average, hiring managers spend just 10 seconds looking at your application. That’s why we have our success team: To give you the best chance of being interviewed.

‍

Our success team read through your screening questions and CV in detail. And ensure that all the most relevant and important information is clearly sign-posted. They also then speak to the hiring manager, and fight your corner. 

‍

Given our business model (we only get paid if you get hired), we are incentivised to get you the job (we only get paid when clients hire) - so are always here to help present you with the best possible chance.

‍

Getting you the feedback you deserve

‍

Every application must receive a response. Whilst this is harder in a competitive market, there are no excuses for it not happening. As such, this is a central KPI for our team, and last year 93.6% of applicants heard back within two weeks. 

‍

And as far as possible, helpful and constructive feedback should be included. We have been working hard to ensure that we can live up to our values and provide as much information as we can about your application to you. 

‍

We are also focused this year on getting more actionable feedback from clients around why you’re not being progressed. When this is not possible, we are committed to provide you with an overview of what the candidates who are progressing have.

‍

We know there’s a long way for us, and even further for the industry to go. This will be a continued strategic focus for us this year, and we welcome any feedback or thoughts you might have.

‍

Launching a coaching service

‍

Last year, Rich, our co-founder, launched OnUpBeyond to help you build your best career in or beyond consulting / finance. 

‍

We’ve always wanted to offer more to our community, and are delighted that this has come to fruition this year. Focused on how you progress in your career, it offers courses, coaching, and roundtables to connect with a peer group of like-minded professionals. If you'd like to know more:

• Register for free so you’re kept up to date with 2025’s offerings 

‍

Launching a Search proposition for our more senior members of the community

‍

As our community has become more experienced, we’ve increasingly worked on more senior roles. In the last year we helped more companies than ever to hire Chief Executive Officers (CEOs), Chief Strategy Officers (CSOs), Chief Transformation Officers (CTOs), Chief Commercial Officers (CCOs), Chief Financial Officers (CFOs) and Operating Partners. 

‍

This level of hiring requires a more hands-on approach, for both our clients and for our candidates. As such, we are excited to be launching our Search proposition focused on Chief Strategy Officers and Chief Transformation at Enterprise businesses and Operating Partners in Private Equity (coming in Q2 2025).

‍

If your next move will be at C-Suite level, please do keep your eyes open for the next update.

‍

More content and insights to help you make informed decisions

‍

This year, we are focused on driving even more insights from our rich data set. We are in a unique position to share compensation, data and insights.

‍

In case you missed any of it, here are our most popular articles of 2024 - which cover compensation and hiring trends.

‍

• Compensation Market Index
• Global Pay and Satisfaction Index
• Why do consultancies produce so many CEOs?

‍

Final words

‍

We know how hard this market is, and we are here to help however we can. We also are constantly striving to improve. So if you have any thoughts on what else we should, and could, be doing - please don’t hesitate to email us at info@movemeon.com. We thank you in advance for any thoughts (and thanks also to those of you who kindly took the time to provide feedback in 2024 - it really is enormously helpful).

‍

In the meantime, we wanted to say a big thank you for trusting us to help, and celebrate all the new jobs you found last year… 

Discover Your Value with the Global Pay Index

‍Unlock exclusive access to the Movemeon Global Pay Index, the definitive resource for professionals seeking clarity on market compensation trends. Dive into data collected from 4,000+ global responses to benchmark your earnings across industries, seniority levels, and job types—whether permanent or freelance. With insights on pay by country, gender pay gaps, and working hours, this tool empowers you to negotiate better, plan your career, or benchmark hiring strategies.

‍

The Global Pay Index is designed to support you:

• Benchmark Your Salary: See how your pay compares across industries, job functions, and seniority levels globally.
• Plan Your Career: Gain insights into pay trends, job satisfaction, and working hours to make informed career decisions.
• Negotiate with Confidence: Use comprehensive market data to strengthen your salary and contract negotiations.
• Explore Global Pay Trends: Understand pay variations by country and how freelance compares to permanent roles.
• Close Pay Gaps: Access gender pay gap data and identify discrepancies across industries and roles.
• Stay Competitive: Employers can use the index to attract and retain top talent with competitive offers.
  ‍

Get exclusive access today and make data-driven career or hiring decisions!

‍

To explore the full data and make informed decisions for your future - please simply provide your email address in the form below:

A disproportionate number of CEOs have worked in top-consulting firms.

OnDesk recently ran the numbers - they looked at the CEOs of the US’s largest operating companies and analysed where people had started their careers. Of the top 8 most common companies, 6 are consultancies:

‍

‍

In this article, we look into what makes consulting alumni so well-suited to lead organisations. And what this means for you hiring for leadership positions in your team and organisation.

If you'd like to find out more about senior hiring with Movemeon get in touch with our team here.

‍

Diverse exposure: versatility for complex challenges

Consultants are exposed to a wide array of industries, challenges, and business models during their careers. This breadth of experience enables them to adapt quickly to new environments, making them invaluable as leaders in dynamic or fast-changing markets.

High-Profile Example:

• Indra Nooyi, former CEO of PepsiCo, leveraged her experience at BCG to navigate PepsiCo’s global expansion and drive innovation in sustainability.

Consultants’ ability to analyse diverse scenarios and develop tailored solutions makes them particularly adept at addressing complex, multi-faceted challenges. This versatility can mean the difference between an executive who only fits into a niche and one who can lead across functions and industries.

‍

Analytical proficiency: a data-driven and structured approach to leadership

Consultants are trained to analyse problems methodically, using data to guide decision-making. For CEOs, this analytical rigour is crucial in navigating uncertainty and driving strategic priorities.

High-Profile Example:

• James Gorman, Chairman and former CEO of Morgan Stanley, used his McKinsey-honed analytical skills to stabilise and grow Morgan Stanley following the 2008 financial crisis.

Hiring managers should value candidates with consulting backgrounds for their ability to synthesise complex information into actionable insights—a skill essential for steering organisations through uncertainty and change.

‍

Strategic insight: long-term thinking for organisational growth

A key focus of consulting is strategy development—defining clear goals, aligning resources, and ensuring execution. This mirrors the core responsibilities of a CEO, making consultants natural fits for leadership roles.

High-Profile Example:

• Sheryl Sandberg, former COO of Meta (Facebook), transitioned from McKinsey to redefine Facebook’s operational strategy, contributing significantly to its growth trajectory.

Candidates with consulting experience bring a proven ability to think beyond immediate challenges and design strategies that position organisations for long-term success.

‍

Extensive networks: access to key relationships

Consultants develop extensive professional networks through interactions with senior executives, cross-functional teams, and industry leaders. These connections often become a powerful asset in leadership roles.

High-Profile Example:

• Sundar Pichai, CEO of Alphabet (Google), utilised the network and insights gained from his time at McKinsey to transition into leadership in the competitive tech industry.

When considering candidates, hiring managers should recognise that consultants often bring with them a wealth of professional relationships that can facilitate partnerships, mentorships, and market opportunities.

‍

Leadership development: coached for executive excellence

Consulting firms invest heavily in leadership development, equipping their employees with early management responsibility and structured training programs. Consultants are often tasked with leading client projects and managing teams early in their careers, giving them a head start in developing the skills required for executive roles.

High-Profile Example:

• Julie Sweet, CEO of Accenture, exemplifies how consulting firms prepare individuals for leadership, transitioning seamlessly into executive roles by leveraging her extensive consulting experience.

This preparation translates into candidates who are not only strategic thinkers but also adept at managing teams, driving results, and navigating high-pressure environments.

‍

What this means for your team and your company

Consultants are a great succession plan for your Board. They will bring with them a broad skillset, proven leadership ability and clear strategic vision. Whilst this is critical in leadership roles, it’s also an invaluable skillset to have throughout your organisation. 

Despite the number of well documented redundancies across consulting, it hasn’t made the market any easier to hire in. We typically find clients are looking for an ex-consultant who has already made the adjustment into “industry”, be that a PE-backed company or an Enterprise business. They’ve therefore built up a track record of delivery and “operating” over the previous 5-10 years.

If you’d like to learn more about how you would bring this type of talent to your team or company, please do let us know.

‍

Earlier in the year, our data showed us that it was the best time to hire in a decade, with the highest level of interest per role we’d seen since COVID. We’ve conducted further analysis, looking at what the bearing this has had on compensation dynamics in the market.

To find out more about hiring with Movemeon get in touch with our team here.

Using our proprietary data, we’ve analysed over one and a half million data points, and seen a seismic shift in the market. Two years ago, there was a large gap between the compensation candidates’ expected for a new job and how much employers were offering. Within just two years this has dropped to historic lows - suggesting that many companies “over-corrected” their salaries and are now effectively over-paying for new joiners.

In this article we look at how the compensation gap has changed over the last five years, driven primarily by supply-demand dynamics. We look at how this varies  by company type, suggesting corporates have over-corrected their compensation, as well as Private Equity and Consultancies but for very different reasons.

Finally, we look at how this picture varies by alumni firm. McKinsey, BCG and Bain alumni have historically commanded a premium in the market, but we’re seeing early indications that this premium is decreasing. MBB expectations have only increased by a modest (and below inflation) level of 2% compared with 4% for the Big4 and 6% for boutiques.

Introducing the Movemeon compensation index and what it says about the market

Below you’ll see how the Movemeon compensation index has tracked over the last five years. We’ve analysed over one and a half million data points going back five years, looking at the gap between expectation and reality when it comes to comp. We see this as a measure of “friction” in the market, and an early indicator of inflationary pressures on wage growth.

For the numbers to make sense, it’s worth a quick recap of who’s in the Movemeon network;

• It’s global: our 75k members are based across the world, with our main hubs in UK, France, DACH, Middle East, APAC and US
• Everyone has worked in a leading consulting or accounting firm: 45% are ex-McKinsey, BCG and Bain; 30% are leading strategy firms; the remainder are the Big4
• They are future leaders and Board members: it’s well documented that McKinsey is the largest future leader factory in the world. The number of ex-consulting and accounting professionals leading companies (from Fortune 500 to PE and VC backed scale-ups) is astounding

How to interpret the numbers:

• 0-25: There’s only a small difference between candidate expectations and compensation offered In other words, it’s a highly efficient market
• 25-50: There’s a manageable difference between candidate expectations and compensation offered.
• 50-75: There’s a marked gap between candidate expectations and compensation offered - a high friction market.
• 75-100: There’s a large and unsustainable gap between candidate expectations and compensation offered - a very high friction market
  ‍

Supply-demand in the hiring market is the driver behind the compensation dynamics

When we plot our hiring and compensation indexes together, it’s clear there’s a very strong causal relationship (an 85% negative correlation). The more in demand ex-consultants are, the more their compensation expectations increase, resulting in a larger compensation gap between job offers and expectations.

‍

‍

Are you now over-paying for new joiners? The compensation gap is at an all-time low

Over the past 5 years, we’ve seen the gap between expectations and job offers hit historic highs of 22% in 2021, before falling way down to  6%, -9% below the historic average.

‍

We had assumed the drivers of the decrease in this gap were candidates re-adjusting their expectations downwards. This is historically what we’ve seen in very competitive hiring markets.

But this has not been the case. Over the past year, compensation expectations within our community have still increased at a healthy rate.  The real driver of the expectation gap has been a very high increase in compensation being offered for jobs. This is clearly unsustainable in the longer-term, and feels like an over-correction in response to the higher consulting salaries and candidate expectations we saw in 2022-23.

For our latest salary information, you can view our benchmarking here.

Over-correction, hard to recruit talent, or paying for the best - how PEs, scale-ups, consultancies and advisories have reacted

When we look at our compensation index by company type, there are some very interesting trends.

Large corporates have a compensation gap of just 2%. This is much lower than historic averages, suggesting they have overcorrected compared with candidates’ expectations.

Scale-ups on the other hand have a gap of 13%. This is in line with historic averages  and suggests that a focus on profitability combined with lower levels of VC-funding have ensured there hasn’t been an over-correction.

In the advisory space the picture is quite surprising. It’s been widely reported that it’s a tough market for consultancies, however, what our data shows is that those who are recruiting are prepared to pay a large premium - 8% in large consultancies, 5% in boutiques. We think this is being driven for two reasons: firstly, firms that are recruiting are growing, and as such are in a position to be paying for high performing (more expensive) talent; secondly, it is a hard market in which to attract ex-consultants given slow growth in the industry as a whole. To make it more appealing, bigger packages are being offered.

Finally, Private Equity is also paying a premium to outstrip expectations. This comes as no surprise and is also in line with historic norms in the sector. Private Equity is focused on attracting the very best, and as such is prepared to pay top decile compensations.

Compensation trends offer further evidence that McKinsey, BCG and Bain have been harder hit by the downturn than other strategy firms

When you look at how compensation expectations have changed by alumni firm, an interesting trend emerges. McKinsey, BCG, Bain alumni have seen the lowest increase in their expectations - a modest (and below inflation) figure of 2.3%. This is broadly in line with other strategy firms, but under half what we’re seeing alumni of boutiques and the Big4 demand.
‍

‍

Despite the higher increase in expectation from boutique and Big4 alumni,  McKinsey, BCG and Bain alumni are still paid a premium of over 12% compared to the median compensation.

If you’d like to find out more about how Movemeon can support your hiring, please get in touch.

Are you interested in building your best career, in or beyond consulting & finance?

We've supported 70,000+ professionals & 5,000+ organisations. Our courses give you action plans that are proven to work, no matter your career stage or goals.

You can explore our coaching and courses over on OnUpBeyond.

‍

Every fortnight or so I run a poll on my LinkedIn. Given my area of expertise, the polls explore consulting careers (in and after consulting) - why people start, why they leave and what they leave for. Typically 600-1,200 people join in (a pretty decent sample size) and overall, these polls have been viewed by over 500,000 people with more than 15,000 participants.

Why do I do these polls about post consulting careers?

Well, unlike many more linear careers, most consulting careers involve leaving consulting. So for a consultant, plotting a career is a bit of a minefield. And if you're trying to hire consulting-trained professionals, how best to attract them can be equally mind-boggling. So, I find the results of these polls particularly enlightening. Why?

• For employers (HR and hiring managers inside and outside of consulting firms), they unlock the secret sauce in retaining or attracting consulting-trained professionals (into roles like strategy, transformation, project management, commercial development, chief of staff etc) by shining a light on how most people think about their consulting careers.
• For consultants, they shed light on how others in the consulting industry feel and behave and accordingly, give you clear references for plotting your consulting career - either in or away from consulting itself.

In this article, I've collated 11 recent polls into 3 topics:

1. Firstly: "Starting a consulting career - why?"
2. Secondly: "Leaving consulting - why?"
3. And finally: "Leaving consulting - what for?"

So, let's get into the data...

Starting a consulting career - why?

Summary: simply put, the majority of people who start a consulting career...

• Don't regret the time spent in consulting (83%);
• Didn't join intending for a lifelong consulting career (88%) / did join as a means to an end (skills, network);
• Don't regret leaving consulting (93%) and;
• Would have been more likely to stay / would return if pay, progression and, especially, working hours improved (80%).

Consultants & former consultants - do you regret the time you spent / are spending in consulting?

Results: (link to data)

When you joined a consulting firm, was it as a "means to an end", or did you envisage a whole career in a consulting firm?

Results below (link to original data)

Do you regret leaving consulting?

Results below (link to original data)

What's the main reason you'd consider switching consulting firms / moving back to consulting?

Results below (link to original data)

Leaving consulting - why?

Summary: simply put, the majority of people leave a consulting career (i.e, leave a permanent role in a consulting firm) in order to...

• Improve their work-life balance / working hours which has..,.
• Deteriorated further during / thanks to covid

What's the main reason you left / would consider leaving consulting?

Results below (link to original data)

Leaving consulting - was work-life balance the main reason (or would it be, if you were to leave in the future)?

Results below (link to original data)

Consultants - how has your work-life balance changed through covid? I'm working..

Results below (link to original data)

Leaving consulting - what for?

Summary: simply put, consultants transition their careers out of consulting along the following lines...

• Scale-ups are the most sought-after company type, but the full range of organisations is appealing (the consulting skill set is extremely transferable so most options are open)
• Most consultants want their career to end up in a P&L or operational leadership role (CEO/COO track) - the most successful companies at hiring ex-consulting talent can show a path to these (typically using strategy / transformation teams as a stepping stone / leadership talent pipeline)
• Freelance consulting is becoming increasingly popular
• Current & former consultants want more data when it comes to choosing post-consulting careers, especially regarding compensation and work-life balance. We're on a mission to provide that - check it out here.

Consultants - what company type do you find most appealing (as a post consulting home)?

Results below (link to original data)

Current & former consultants - what job type would you most like your career to lead to (or for more senior folk, which has it lead to)?

Results below (link to original data)

Freelancing - Are you more of less likely than 12 months ago to consider doing some freelance work?

Results below (link to original data)

Would it be helpful to know which post-consulting careers have the best pay, working hours & job satisfaction?

Results below (link to original data)

Popular Resources

If you're trying to assess your options for a post-consulting career, here are some popular resources:

• Private equity - 29 questions to ask
• What is a Chief of Staff and why do they get hired?
• How to be successful as a freelance consultant
• 30 interviews with industry leaders (who used to be consultants)
  ‍

‍

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive our exclusive insights and career tips straight into your inbox every month:

Given the intense competition, receiving an offer to join a private equity firm is quite a significant achievement, and the temptation to accept the offer as soon as you receive it without having done any proper due diligence is thus huge. Overlooking this crucial step of the job-hunting process can lead to serious disappointment in the future and the fast-moving private equity industry is no exception in that respect.

Below are 29 questions that you should ask to ensure you make an enlightened decision.

Fund strategy & positioning

1. How many funds and/or product lines does the firm operate?
   More and more Private equity firms are diversifying their activity to include hedge funds (i.e. public market investing) or debt vehicles. Each business line requires a particular approach and investment strategy. As a consequence, this can give you a feel for the variety of the work (in terms of investment type) that you will face. Beware though; like any organisation, a firm that spreads across too many lines is likely to feel a bit disorganised.
   
   
2. What kind of assets does the company invest in? There are primarily two types of assets in private equity: companies and infrastructure. Again, referring to the first post of my series, the nature of the work differs between those two environments.
   
   
3. What is the fund's investment strategy? Each fund will more or less strictly position itself within a spectrum going from "distressed" (i.e. underperforming and close to bankruptcy) to "glamorous" or "high-growth" assets. The price paid but more importantly, the type of work and situations you will encounter will depend on the strategy. In a distressed fund, you should expect to be involved in heavy restructuring and cost-cutting programs. In a growth context, you will spend much of your time finding ways to develop the business' top-line.
   
   
4. What is the size of the fund? What is the fund's sweet spot in terms of enterprise value or equity cheque? As mentioned in the first post of this series, the type of work you will do will significantly differ if you join a small-cap (<$250m roughly), mid-cap ($250m to $1bn) or large-cap fund. The equity cheque (i.e. the amount the fund itself invests in a given company) is intimately linked to the fund size since a fund will typically make between 8 and 20 investments as well as to the enterprise value sweet spot since roughly 50% of the acquisition price will be paid by raising debt.
   
   
5. Which stage of the company's lifecycle does the fund invest in? As mentioned in an earlier post, private equity funds as a whole cover the entire company lifecycle, from birth (seed or VC) to maturity (LBO). You should expect VCs to be more "gut-feel" based whereas LBOs require deeper due diligence and involve a significant amount of financial structuring (absent in VCs which very often can only raise equity).
   
   
6. Where is the fund present? Where does the fund invest? On one hand, a global fund will limit country-specific risk exposure. On the other hand, the more global the fund, the more you will have to travel - especially if the office network is relatively loose, e.g. only one office to cover the whole of Europe.
   
   Practically speaking, the geographical remit is defined in two ways. First, investors sign a term sheet that formally defines the areas where the General Partners (or "GPs", i.e. the members of the private equity firm) can and cannot invest. Second, and more importantly, GPs have their own "comfort zone", which is often a subset of the theoretically authorised area. This question is important for you as it will determine the amount of travel you can expect from this job as well as the extent of the cultural gap you may face when meeting with management teams.
   
   
7. What kind of industries does the fund invest in? The majority of funds are "sector-agnostic" and will invest indifferently in all industries. Some (most often smaller ones) have specialised in one or a handful of industries, typically Retail or Tech.
   
   
8. Does the fund do minority and/or majority deals? By definition, if the fund only does minority deals it will rarely be able to exert full control over the company and therefore you should expect more time to be spent on the due diligence - to ensure that the business "as it is" is a good one. This situation is relatively rare in private equity as opposed to hedge funds
   
   
9. Is the fund committed or raised on a deal-by-deal basis? A committed fund will offer more stability and less dependence on market conditions. Furthermore, a firm seeking investor funding on a deal-by-deal basis may feel the pressure to invest regularly to keep momentum with investors, even if the climate or opportunities are not optimal.

Track record

1. When did the firm raise funds for the last time? This question will give you a feel for the type of work you will be doing. If the fund is recent (less than 2-3 years), you should expect to spend most of your time sourcing deals and executing investments for this new fund. If the fund is older, portfolio management ("harvesting") should take a growing share of your bandwidth.
   
   
2. Has the firm raised more than one fund? First-time funds can appear attractive because of their entrepreneurial nature and their subsequent potential. If the first fund is successful the second will be larger and the team will grow, potentially creating "upward gaps". However, growth in private equity is more often achieved through external hiring rather than internal promotion, so you should always consider career upside potential with a bit of caution.
   
   
3. How does the actual fundraising amount compare with the fundraising target? In the current environment, with liquidity being more than abundant, a fund not meeting its fundraising target has run out of favour with investors and such momentum is very difficult to reverse, so I advise you to stay away. Some funds exceed their target, but many will stop when they reach it in order not to overstretch their teams.
   
   
4. How does the latest actual fundraising amount compare with previous actuals? Fund growth is a clear indicator of momentum and expected team size evolution. In particular, if the firm has been raising a decreasing amount of money, it means investors are less and less convinced and, unless the firm manages to come up with a series of mind-blowing investments, you should expect the trend to continue and therefore the team to keep shrinking.
   
   
5. How have previous funds performed? Given the illiquid and long-term nature of private equity (funds have a 10-year lifespan), it takes time for struggling funds to be entirely wiped out of the market. An early indicator consists of benchmarking the latest funds' IRR. If those IRRs are disappointing, it will only be a matter of time before investors are free to switch their funds to another destination.
   
   
6. Has the fund made recent investments? A fund may decide to slow or fasten its investment pace depending on market conditions. However, a fund that has not put any money to work over the last 18 months is more likely struggling to source interesting deals and this should raise a flag.
   
   
7. How fragmented is the Limited Partner (or "LPs", i.e. investor) base? I am always concerned with "one-LP" funds where one investor has the practical right of life and death over the fund. I believe this not only creates uncertainty about the future of the fund in case of headwinds (both at fund and investor level) but also there is a risk of seeing the LP interfering with investment decisions (creating useless friction).

Operating model

1. How large is the firm globally? In London? A classic question. All funds started with very small teams and an entrepreneurial spirit, but some have grown so much that this early flavour may have disappeared quite significantly.
   
   
2. Are there other offices? If so, where? Where are the headquarters? What is the role of London? The worst case for you is to join a US-based fund which considers London (and Europe in general) as non-core to their strategy and as such does not give you a lot of consideration and does not involve you in the investment decisions. Fortunately, London is a strong financial place and such situations are rare (at least rarer than if you were applying in Paris or Madrid).
   
   
3. Are there investment committee members based in London? Building on the previous question, a negative answer will likely indicate that the office has been primarily set up to perform local sourcing and execute deals when told by the headquarters, which reduces the amount of autonomy you will enjoy and subsequently the interest of the job.
   
   
4. How is staffing decided? Are there teams dedicated to particular geographies/industries/product lines? This question will help you assess whether you are going to develop particular expertise or whether you are going to remain quite a generalist. Both approaches have their own pluses and minuses, but in any case, you would like to ensure that your prospective employer does not plan to specialise you in an industry you do not fancy.
   
   
5. Is there a dedicated operations team? If so, how large is it, what are its remit and background? If an operations team exists, you should expect to be consequently less involved in commercial and operational aspects of the due diligence and/or portfolio management.

People & culture

1. Where do people come from? PE professionals typically come from a mix of investment banking, consulting, accountancy/Transaction Services and Corporate. The way of approaching investments is influenced by this background.
   
   
2. How would you define the fund's culture? Some funds have an American culture, which as a Frenchman I would define as direct and energetic, others have a more British inclination, softer and possibly more political. This does not mean that one is generally better than the other but you need to make sure that the culture fits your way of working and interacting with others.
   
   
3. How many (net) additions to the team have there been in the last 24 months? In the investment team alone? The "fund size evolution" question, should help you assess the momentum the firm is benefiting from. A shrinking team is almost always a bad sign - the fund is losing momentum or struggling to attract talents to fill the gaps.
   
   
4. How many people have left the fund over the last 24 months? If you exclude "defined-length" contracts (such as the Associates program), churn should be low: jobs in private equity are rare, and people tend to stick to their seats if their role is interesting and if they believe the firm has decent future prospects. If churn is high (say more than 30% of the firm was renewed over the last 2 years), at least one of the two previously mentioned conditions was broken.
   
   
5. Who are the senior sponsors of the fund? Each private equity fund is chaired and/or advised by highly respected individuals within the investment industry. Such personalities act as a stamp of approval and tend to facilitate fundraising. Conversely, you should proceed carefully with not or weakly endorsed funds.
   
   
6. Can I meet the rest of the team? Private equity firms are small companies and the personal fit is even more important than in consulting - imagine that you will spend many years working with the same people on a series of projects. I thus encourage you to meet as many team members as possible to assess this fit.

Compensation and career path

1. Who has access to carried interest? How is carried interest computed? Carried interest (i.e. the performance fee that general partners receive when their investments generate an IRR in excess of a certain threshold) amounts to a very significant share of your compensation, especially at senior level. Always useful to know when you will be entitled to receive a share of the pie. Most often carried interest is computed and shared at fund level; however, a few funds (e.g. CVC Capital Partners) are famous for their "deal-by-deal carry structure".
   
   
2. What is the typical career path? You need to understand whether there is a "glass ceiling" that you will never be able to go through. Many US funds have formal fixed-term Associate programs which imply that you will need to leave after 2-3 years. Other funds may encourage investment professionals to leave once they reach a given tenure if there is no room for additional senior managers or partners. In any case, you should feel free to ask for specific examples.

FAQs

1. What are the potential drawbacks or challenges associated with joining a private equity fund that has recently raised funds (less than 2-3 years old), and how might the job responsibilities differ in comparison to joining a more established fund?
   
   Joining a private equity fund that has recently raised funds (less than 2-3 years old) may involve a greater emphasis on sourcing deals and executing investments for the new fund. This could mean a higher focus on building the fund's portfolio and establishing its presence in the market. The nature of the work may lean more towards the early stages of fund management, with portfolio management gaining prominence as the fund matures over time.
   
   
2. How can I assess the cultural fit within a private equity firm, especially considering the different cultural inclinations between American and British-founded funds mentioned in the post?
   
   Assessing cultural fit within a private equity firm involves understanding the underlying cultural dynamics, such as American or British inclinations. For instance, American cultures might be characterized as direct and energetic, while British cultures may be perceived as softer and possibly more political. You should consider your own working style and preferences to ensure alignment with the cultural nuances of the firm, as this can significantly impact job satisfaction and collaboration.
   
   
3. In the context of private equity fund size and fundraising, what are the implications for my career progression and job responsibilities based on whether the fund exceeds its fundraising target, stops at the target, or falls short of the target?
   
   The fundraising performance of a private equity fund can influence career progression and job responsibilities. If a fund exceeds its fundraising target, it might indicate strong investor confidence and potential team growth, creating upward career opportunities. Conversely, a fund that falls short of its target may face challenges, potentially leading to a shrinking team. Understanding the fund's fundraising success provides valuable insights into its momentum and the trajectory of the team, helping candidates make informed decisions about their long-term career prospects.
   
   

Continue reading the private equity series:

• 12 usual activities of a private equity associate
• The double-edged sword of working in private equity
• 9 principles to help you break in
• All private equity funds were not created equal
• When to look for the boarding gate?

Subscribe to our newsletter below to receive our exclusive insights and career tips straight into your inbox every month:

Explore jobs at Private Equity Firms on our free platform - it takes 2 minutes to sign up here